Lummi Island Wild Reviews

Lummi Island Wild has an overall rating of 4.7 based on 61 reviews. Customer feedback on Lummi Island Wild is mixed: Lummi Island Wild reviewers highlight positive aspects like excellent seafood quality, sustainable fishing practices, reliable shipping and packaging, which strongly appeal to health-conscious seafood lovers, sustainability-mindful families, serious home cooks who value premium wild-caught fish. However, Lummi Island Wild is often criticized for its remium pricing, shipping cost if minimum not met, limited customization of a-la-carte selections.

4.7/5.0

61 reviews

5 Stars

15

4 Stars

7

3 Stars

0

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Lummi Island Wild Reviews (61)
Tracy-seals
May 22, 2026
"Tastes like the real deal"
I’m assuming from the clean, fresh taste that this is genuinely wild caught because it doesn’t have that weird processed flavor some fish has. Just tastes like real fish, simple and good.
santo.Schneider
May 19, 2026
"Heads up: their communication is actually solid"
Just a quick heads-up for anyone thinking about ordering: my experience was really straightforward. They kept me in the loop the whole time after I placed the order, and I got emails whenever there was an update or change. I never felt like I was stuck guessing what was happening. Everything was clear, simple, and it arrived when they said it would. I’d order from them again.
tracey-Parr
May 18, 2026
"They made cooking salmon way too easy"
I ordered from Lummi Island Wild i kind of blame them for making me feel like I actually know what I’m doing with fish now. The thawing and pan-cooking tips were super easy to follow, which was a big help because I usually manage to dry salmon out somehow lol. This time it came out really nice. The site was simple to use too, so no complaints there. I’d definitely order again.
joyce1998
May 17, 2026
"Easy gift order, no fuss"
Sent a salmon box to my brother as a gift and it showed up right on time. He said it was packed really well and tasted great, so that was a win. Ordering was easy too, no hassle at all tbh
sheldonmckelvey9513
April 15, 2026
"Honestly, really good salmon"
I was happy with this salmon. It tasted really fresh, and I’m picky about that because I can’t stand when salmon has that strong fishy taste. This didn’t have that at all. Also, it cooked up nicely, and yeah, the flavor was just really clean and tasty.
annette.Kimbrough
April 07, 2026
"They handled my refund and replacement without the runaround"
Part of my order had an issue, and I was expecting the usual back-and-forth where a company acts like they’re hoping you’ll just give up. But Lummi Island Wild got back to me quickly and didn’t make the whole thing awkward or difficult.

They offered both a refund and a replacement, which felt fair to me. Shipping problems happen, so I’m more interested in whether a company tries to dodge responsibility or actually fixes it. In this case, they did right by me
Emma_mecca86
March 14, 2026
"Pretty happy, even if I’m torn"
I’ve usually been loyal to another seafood company, so ordering from Lummi Island Wild felt a little like cheating on my usual go-to. But i was happy with it. The fish tasted really fresh, everything was packed neatly, and there was no weird smell or messy leak situation when it arrived. I do wish the shipping updates were a bit clearer, and it’s definitely not the cheapest option out there. Still, when I’m in the mood for really good seafood, I could see myself ordering from them again.
PamelaMartin
March 03, 2026
"Good fish, but the wait was annoying"
I ordered from Lummi Island Wild because I liked how upfront they are about sustainable sourcing and where the fish actually comes from. It felt a lot better than just grabbing something random at the grocery store and hoping for the best.

The fish tasted fresh and everything was packed well, so no complaints there. The only thing that frustrated me was the waiting, I kept checking for updates and it felt like it took longer than I wanted. Prices are definitely on the higher side too, so it’s a 4-star experience for me, but I’d still probably order again
KathrynRoberts
March 03, 2026
"Good seafood selection overall"
They had a nice variety of seafood, and I was able to find most of what I was looking for. It felt like a solid selection overall, if that makes sense.
hello_catherine465
February 19, 2026
"Arrived faster than I thought"
My order got here quicker than expected, and the fish was still frozen solid when it arrived. Overall, it was a really smooth experience
wayne.Thomas
February 13, 2026
"Fresh and tasty, but not exactly cheap"
I ordered the salmon and thought it was really good. It tasted fresh, was packed nicely, and arrived in great shape. The price is definitely on the higher side, so I’m curious if other people feel like it’s worth it too, but for what I got, it felt fair. I’d order again, just probably not every week.
hello_david481
February 06, 2026
"Fresh, tasty fish, though a little expensive"
I really enjoyed the fish here. It tasted fresh and clean, and there wasn’t any weird fishy smell, which I always appreciate. The portions were solid too. The only downside is that it’s a bit on the pricey side, so I’d take off one star for that. Personally, I still think the quality makes it worth trying.
Blake_lucas90
February 03, 2026
"Fresh salmon, really tasty"
The salmon arrived nice and cold, and it seemed super fresh (always a relief with fish). We cooked it that night and it tasted great, no complaints at all.
JohnIde_36
February 03, 2026
"Order was right and everything was fine"
I placed the order while I was sitting at home trying to get a few things done, and when it showed up, everything matched what I had picked out. No missing items, no mix-ups, nothing weird. Straightforward experience overall.
CANNON
January 31, 2026
"Quick, helpful response about my order"
I reached out to lummiislandwild.com with a question about my order and expected to wait a while, because that’s usually how these things go. But they got back to me really fast, answered my questions clearly, and were friendly about it. No confusing back-and-forth or making things harder than they needed to be. Just straightforward help, which is all you really want. I’d definitely order from them again.
PaulaSmith_15
January 26, 2026
"Super easy site to use"
I just found what I needed really quickly and didn’t have any hassle at all.
charlene_Garrett71
January 15, 2026
"Showed up frozen just like everyone said"
I was a little nervous about ordering frozen fish online, so I definitely checked what other people were saying first. Thankfully, my order arrived in great shape and everything was still frozen solid when I opened the box. The dry ice was almost gone, but it clearly did its job. No leaks, no weird smell, and the packages all looked good. Really happy with how it arrived
MCDONALD
December 31, 2025
"Pretty happy with my fish subscription"
I’ve been getting this fish subscription for a few months now, and it’s been great. Everything shows up frozen solid and packed really well, with no weird smell or freezer burn. I also like not having to think about picking up decent seafood at the store. I had to pause my order once and customer service made it easy. No complaints from me.
michael.Charette
December 27, 2025
"Pretty decent portions, I think"
I wasn’t totally sure what to expect, but the portion sizes felt fair to me. Not too much, not too little, just about right.
richardpotter4819
December 21, 2025
"They always seem to have what I need"
Every time I’ve gone in, the stuff I was looking for was actually in stock and I didn’t have to deal with any hassle. whoever runs this place is to blame for making it way too easy to get in and out

View More Reviews

Have a question about Lummi Island Wild?
lummiislandwild

Lummi Island Wild Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.